Pages

Wednesday, 27 May 2026

Why do you want to be a woman?

 Questions, questions. 

I've often been asked "So why do you want to be a woman?"

It's the wrong question. I don't want to be a woman. Being trans is something that I am, that happened to me, that I have no say in, like my genes or skin colour. There's nothing I can do about it. I wish I wasn't trans but there we are. I do what I can with it in the circumstances I find myself in.

"Are you a woman?" 

I'd like to be treated as one.

"What, even though women have worse pay, suffer more violence and are usually second-class citizens?"

Even that. 

"But you have been a man."

We all play our roles in life. Your behaviour as a parent is not the same as your behavior at work or in the gym or whatever other roles you have. You act the part and stay safe.

"But why wear skirts? Most of us women wear trousers."

True, and so do I quite often, but a skirt gives me a more obvious feminine shape, it signals femininity more clearly and, since I've been forced to wear trousers for much of my life, I'd rather have something more obviously different. What we wear is not just for warmth and decency but is also a strong social signal. 

"But can't you wear a skirt for men, like a kilt?"

A kilt is a man's garment and that's not the deal here. 

And so on. I've been interrogated like this many times, usually by women, some out of curiosity, some more aggressively. It's sometimes hard to judge what is interest expressed poorly and what is rude intrusion.

"What's your real name?"

Sue.

"No, I mean your real name."

Still Sue. 

"So, like, have you had the operation?"

Have you always been rude? 

Is this how you normally approach strangers?  

It gets boring, sometimes weird, always uncomfortable, and sometimes nasty. As trans people, I think we've all been there. If you're not trans, please simply get to know your trans person in a normal way, and the answers to your questions will doubtless emerge in due time.

 

Blue nails, and other colours

So I've been experimenting with new nail varnishes and I tried the blue one, a colour I've never used before. But blue is for boys, right? (see conversations above.)

 

It needed two coats as it was very watery, which is one downside of getting a cheap one. The upside of getting a cheap one is that you don't lose much money if you don't like it, and so far I don't like it.

I want to try it with some sporty grey leggings and a matching blue top just to see if it works better in a casual context but the weather's been a bit too hot for that. It should cool a bit by the weekend and I'll try again.

Actually, the weather is reasonable for late May here, about 30C, and not as bad as some other places in Europe, but it hit very suddenly. Even I like a slow run-up to hot weather, or cold for that matter.

Anyway, the plants are loving it and there's a riot of colour in the hedgerows here and on plants clambering over the lampposts.   

 






I think my nails might look better with one of these shades!

The statue of Spring on the promenade:

 


Sue x  

6 comments:

  1. With the questions thing, I'm struggling to remember if I've ever been asked such things. I'm unsure if I'm just not out & about enough; I'm just lucky; or there's a unknown to me "don't ask the tall lady" protection field operating.

    All that aside, I'm sorry to hear you've had to put up with it. Sometimes the public can be unpleasantly over curious - or just plain rude.

    As to the blue paws, FWIW that colour seems to need a few coats to get the coverage. Personally I rather like it, but if it's not you, it's your choice ❤️

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Lynn.

      My list of typical questions is a synthesis of various conversations over many years, some with close friends, some with total strangers. Some are almost unanswerable, almost like asking "why does life exist?", and some are plain intrusive. It's never comfortable.

      I'm going to try the blue again but I see it as a sporty sort of shade (maybe for no good reason) so Sue the Yoga Lady might appear with it!

      Sue xx

      Delete
  2. "Blue is for boys" is a late (post Victorian) invention. Or maybe more properly inversion, since in the 1800s, blue was regarded as a weak - and therefore feminine - colour, suitable for girls, while pink (being closer to red) was regarded a strong color and suitable for boys.
    (Which puts an interesting take on Reynold's famous 'blue boy' painting).
    But I suspect much comes down to the shade or strngth of blue or pink you are talking about. (When did paintings of Lewis Carrol's start depicting her dressed in blue? Or did that come from Disney?)

    I wanted to have been born a girl from almost as early as I can remember. That ship - and any religious belief - sailed when God failed to respond to any of my nightly prayers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Susie.

      The classic Alice illustrations by Tenniel were, of course, in black and white but later coloured versions seem to prefer yellow or blue and I suspect the latter is tapping into later 19th century "sailor dress" fashions which have blue as the dominant colour. Disney opted for a lighter blue than navy blue but that has probably sealed Alice's sartorial fate now.

      My life would have made a whole load more sense if I had been born a girl, despite all the disadvantages that brings. But not being trans at all is the best option IMHO, fun though one can make the situation at times. I'm not sure "want" is the right word here any more that saying we are "trapped in a man's/woman's body" but our problem is a lack of precise vocabulary and imagery to describe the trans condition. Maybe one could rewrite Alice's topological and logical conundrums and body morphing in a way that illustrates what it is to be trans. There's a challenge for a clever writer.

      Sue xx

      Delete
  3. Blue is not only for boys...it´s one of my favourite colours besides violet/purple. But this blue is very intensive I think and it will raise attraction. And for your entering question.
    That´s a difficulty to answer for me.
    I want to be as a woman when I am out and about. My female side is a part of me and it will probably never dissapear. But am I a woman?
    I truely must say - no. I like the transition into my female side. And therefore I could say I am a transvestite...as I slip into the female role wearing female clothing. Or the expression that pleases me more -a crossdresser. I can´t explain why it is so....it simply is...and I am a woman when Violetta is going out. And I know some people will never understand that. But is would be a big success if people accept this variety of feelings.
    Nice pictures of the blooming bushes.
    I appologize if some of my writing is not in correct english..but I am tired to look after it in the translation apps LOL.
    Hugs and have a good time....and thanks for your ever so kind visits to my blog.
    Violetta

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your English is really good, Violetta. I wish I could speak German as well as you speak English.

      Each trans person experiences their transness with a greater or lesser degree of intensity. Some people have to transition, other people like to show their trans side sometimes. I need to dress as a woman every day and I would like to transition socially but it's too difficult at the moment. I wouldn't transition surgically. So it's different for everyone but the experiences we have are all equally valid.

      Yes, I think the blue is the wrong type of blue. A paler blue would be better. I'm trying black right now.

      Sue xx

      Delete